Kyle Whittingham's seat getting hotter with new Michigan athletic director inbound
Nobody has been in the same football building with Kyle Whittingham the past dozen years more than Jim Harding.

Nobody has been in the same football building with Kyle Whittingham the past dozen years more than Jim Harding.
Michigan football's offensive line coach, who's recently been tabbed as interim offensive coordinator, spent the past 12 seasons in Utah with Kyle Whittingham. Only once, 2024, did the program have a losing record − and that came in a year the Utes lost four quarterbacks and were down to their fifth-stringer by season's end.
But this season, at 5-5 − the two haven't experienced anything like this. That it's come in Year 1 in Ann Arbor, a pressure cooker of a college football environment that expects excellence and is reticent to accept outsiders − particularly as losses pile up − only adds to the frustration.
There's been criticism of Whittingham's lack of fire on the sideline, his disconnect with the fanbase and a general aura of nonchalance in embracing some of U-M's traditions, particularly trophy games. Harding, however, says he sees the same man behind the scenes.
"In my opinion, he's as fiery, demanding − trust me, he has no problem yelling at me when I'm wrong," Harding said Wednesday, Nov. 18, at Schembechler Hall. "I think that to me shows that he still has the passion. He still is just trying to − again, not [to] speak for him − trying to figure out what is the formula here at Michigan as we continue to learn each other, if that makes sense."
The question, however, is if he will have more than two more weeks to continue to do so. Michigan is in the process of finalizing Texas A&M athletic director Trev Alberts taking over the same position in Ann Arbor. The expedited search appears to signal the severity of the situation in the eyes of the university's movers and shakers.
Michigan incoming president C. Cybele Raver reportedly called a meeting with the board of regents on Tuesday in advance of the board's scheduled gathering on Thursday. That's when Alberts' name surfaced as U-M's next AD, and with changes in the department's hierarchy, there are naturally questions about what comes next for Whittingham.
U-M's football coach turns 67 on Saturday and wasn't seen as a long-term solution at the onset of his hiring, but rather a stop-gap coach for five years or so to bring stability to the program that needed it and results that his track record showed he could produce.
However, with the wins not following, many believe there's a likelihood Alberts will come in and rip off the Band Aid to usher in a new era.
"[Worrying about that is] not what you can do in this business," said defensive coordinator Jay Hill, who played for Whittingham, when asked about job security. "You can't put too much focus into that, otherwise you lose sight on what's most important."
Whittingham has reiterated throughout the season that he doesn't have social media and doesn't give credence to the outside noise. It's one thing to do as much at his point in life, but it's not the same for the student-athletes between 18 and 23 years old who "look at their phone all the time," Hill said.
For the first time, Hill thought, the scrutiny may have finally worn down his unit in last week's 31-7 loss to Oregon. As for Whittingham, he said he can take the barbs; that's part of his job description. What's much harder to stomach, per his new OC, is this level of losing.
"As competitive as he is, I know that it wears on him to lose," Harding said. "I don't mean this to be come off arrogant or unaware, I honestly don't think he is overly concerned about what people say outside of this building, and I know that that might sound wrong, but I think as a leader ... if your concern is all the other the noise outside, you're doing a disservice to the kids.
"But in terms of how upset he is and bothered by the season, I would say immensely because we have not, in my 12 years with him, we did not have a season [like this]."
WINDSOR: 'Go home!' Michigan fans yelled at Kyle Whittingham after Oregon loss
Whittingham said "the fans deserve better" earlier this week. It's unclear if he will be around long enough to get U-M to a better place. Alberts comes from a program that spends big and is walking into another university that's not afraid to fire the money cannons when needed.
It will be a near $25 million buyout if Whittingham is fired after the season, and that's on top of the nearly $10 million U-M could owe former OC Jason Beck (which will likely be mitigated down when he finds a new job). Alberts has shown plenty of willingness to pull the plug, even at a steep financial cost, like when he was Nebraska AD and fired Scott Frost on Sept. 11, 2022 with a $15 million buyout.
Had he even waited 20 days until Oct. 1, it would've been cut in half to $7.5 million.
One year after U-M brought back just a singular coach who was on staff with the Wolverines in the 2025 regular season (running backs coach Tony Alford), there's a distinct chance there could be another teardown of the staff. It's unclear if wins over No. 4 UCLA or rival Ohio State would even be enough to save this regime, namely Whittingham.
Decisions are about to start rolling in over the next few weeks. Meanwhile, U-M has football to prepare for and must find some way to block out the deafening noise from a growingly resentful fanbase.
"Talking about job security ... I think that's just part of what you sign up for when you're a college football coach, especially at a place like this that has high expectations and standards," Harding said. "I think you just go about your day doing the best you can, and putting the players in position to be successful.
"I hope I'm here and all that, but if you worry about things that you can't control, you're gonna be doing a disservice to the kids that you're in charge of."
Tony Garcia is the Michigan beat writer for the Detroit Free Press. Email him at apgarcia@freepress.com and follow him on X at @RealTonyGarcia.


